Food recall

Paradise Flavors LLC recall: UNICORN Ice-cream base, natural flavors, Artificial Flavoring, Artificial color

Paradise Flavors LLC, of Marathon, FL, recalled UNICORN Ice-cream base, natural flavors, Artificial Flavoring, Artificial color and 38 other products. The FDA's reason: “Undeclared allergen: Milk. Undeclared Color Additives: FD&C red #5, blue #1, red #3, red #40, yellow #5.” The FDA classified it Class I: it could cause serious harm or death. The company began the recall voluntarily on September 27, 2023, and the FDA first listed it in its Enforcement Report of November 22, 2023. The FDA has closed the recall: it found the company did all it reasonably could to remove or correct the product.

How serious

Class I

It could cause serious harm or death

Why

Allergen not on the label

Status

Terminated

Closed January 25, 2024

The recall

Company
Paradise Flavors LLC (Marathon, FL)
Reason, in FDA's words
“Undeclared allergen: Milk. Undeclared Color Additives: FD&C red #5, blue #1, red #3, red #40, yellow #5.”
Where it was sold
Domestic distribution only, within state of Florida. No foreign distribution.
Recall began
, by the company
FDA classified it
First in an FDA Enforcement Report
FDA event number
93169

The 39 products recalled

As the FDA describes them, with the codes that tell whether a package is part of the recall.

  • F-0423-2024 Class I

    UNICORN Ice-cream base, natural flavors, Artificial Flavoring, Artificial color. DISTRIBUTED BY PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 216 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0424-2024 Class I

    MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP, Ice-cream base, Chocolate chips, Artificial Flavoring, Artificial color. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 112 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0425-2024 Class I

    GUAVA JELLY, Ice-cream base, natural flavoring, artificial coloring. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 86 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0426-2024 Class I

    VANILLA, Ice-cream base, Natural flavor, artificial flavor and coloring. Distributed By Paradiose Flavors LLC. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 310 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0427-2024 Class I

    BUTTER PECAN, Ice-cream base, Natural flavor, graham crackers, artificial color, citric acid, artificial flavoring. Paradise Flavors. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 58 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0428-2024 Class I

    PINK GUABA, Ice-cream mix, filtered water, Natural Flavoring, sugar, Artificial color. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0429-2024 Class I

    CAPPUCCINO, Ice-cream base, natural flavoring, artificial flavoring. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 60 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0430-2024 Class I

    SWEET CORN/ELOTE, Ice cream mix, natural flavoring, sea salt. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0431-2024 Class I

    Pina Colada, ice-cream base, natural flavoring, artificial flavoring. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 120 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0432-2024 Class I

    Strawberries and Cream, ice-cream base, natural flavoring. Paradise Flavors LLC. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 86 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0433-2024 Class I

    RUM RAISIN, ice-cream base, artificial flavoring natural fruits, artificial. DISTRIBUTED PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 112 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0434-2024 Class I

    Trail Mix/Frutas Secas, Ice-cream base, dried fruits and nuts, vanilla extract. 9301 Overseas Hwy. Marathon FL 33050. CONTAINS NUTS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0435-2024 Class I

    BANANA BREAD , Ice-cream base, Natural fruit, bread, dehydrated fruit. PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. CONTAINS NUTS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 216 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0436-2024 Class I

    Pistachio, Ice-cream base, Natural Flavors, Artificial Colors. Paradise Flavors. CONTAINS NUTS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 200 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0437-2024 Class I

    KEY LIME CREAMSICLE, Filtered water, ice-cream base, natural flavoring, artificial color, citric acid and carboxymethylcellulose. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 216 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0438-2024 Class I

    CHOCOLATE RAZZBERRY CAKE (GANCITO). INGREDIENTS: Icecream base, Natural flavor, artificial flavoring. Paradise Flavors. 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 72 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0439-2024 Class I

    ARROZ CON LECHE/RICE PUDDING, Ice cream MIX, Filtered water, Natural Rice, cinamon and caramel, DISTRIBUTOR PARADISE FLAVORS LLC, 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0440-2024 Class I

    MAMEY, PARADISE FLAVORS LLC, 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 80 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0441-2024 Class I

    YOGOBERRY (YOGURT WITH FRUITS), Ice cream, Mix Berries, Granola, Honey, Citric acid., PARADISE FLAVORS LLC, 4 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0442-2024 Class I

    FLORIDA SUNRISE/CHEMIS, Paradise Flavors LLC, Ice-cream base, natural flavoring, artificial flavor and color., DISTRIBUTED BY PARADISE FLAVORS LLC, 3 oz, 120 ML. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 108 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0443-2024 Class I

    DULCE DE LECHE, Ice-cream base, Natural flavor, artificial flavor and coloring., Distributed By Paradiose Flavors LLC. 4oz (120 mL). Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 210 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0444-2024 Class I

    CHOCOLATE WITH ALMONDS, ice-cream base, chocolate powder, natural flavoring, PARADISE FLAVORS, 4oz, 120 ML. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0445-2024 Class I

    Ferrero Rocher, Ice-cream base, Hazelnut, Nutella, Penuts, Cacao, Rich Chocolate, Artificial flavoring., DISTRIBUTED BY: PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. 4oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0446-2024 Class I

    BLACKBERRY CHEESECAKE, Ice-cream base, Natural Flavor, Cheese, Butter, crackers., 4 oz (120 ML), PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 58 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0447-2024 Class I

    Pine Nut/Pinon, Ice Cream Bar, Ice cream base, natural flavoring, dehydrated fruit, artificial coloring, 4 oz, Paradise Flavors. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0448-2024 Class I

    PEANUT BUTTER/MAZAPAN, Ice-cream base, Natural Flavor, Artificial Color, sea salt., Distributed by PARADISE FLAVORS LLC, 4 OZ. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 210 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0449-2024 Class I

    Cookies And Cream, distributed by Paradise Flavors LLC, 4 OZ, 120ML, Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 318 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0450-2024 Class I

    MAMEY with sweet and condensed milk, PARADISE FLAVORS, 4 OZ. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0451-2024 Class I

    MAGNUM, ice-cream base, natural flavoring, 4 OZ. DISTRIBUTED BY PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0452-2024 Class I

    EZQUIMAL, ice-cream base, natural flavoring, chocolate cover, penuts. 4 OZ. DISTRIBUTED BY PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0453-2024 Class I

    CHOCOLATE, ice-cream base, chocolate powder, natural flavoring,. PARADISE FLAVORS, 4 OZ, 120 ML. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 115 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0454-2024 Class I

    Avocado, ice-cream base, Natural flavor, artificial coloring. DISTRIBUTED BY PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. 4 OZ. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0455-2024 Class I

    COCONUT/COCO ice cream mix, natural flavors, artificial flavors. 9601 Overseas Hwy, Marathon FL. 100ml 3 oz. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 216 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0456-2024 Class I

    KEY LIME PIE, PARADISE FLAVORS, 9601 Overseas Hwy, Marathon FL. 33050. 4 OZ. 120ml. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 118 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0457-2024 Class I

    CHUNKY MANGO, ice-cream base, natural flavoring, artificial flavor and color. 4 OZ, 120ml. DISTRIBUTED BY: Paradise Flavors LLC. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 56 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0458-2024 Class I

    GUANAVANA (SOURSOP/GUANABANA), ice-cream base, natural flavoring. PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 OZ, 120ml. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 0 from latest production

  • F-0459-2024 Class I

    ORANGE CREAMCYCLE, Filtered water, natural flavoring, artificial color, citric acid and carboxymethylcellulose, PARADISE FLAVORS. 4 OZ, 120ML. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 38 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0460-2024 Class I

    BUBBLEGUM GUMMYBEAR, ice-cream base, artificial flavor. Distributed by: PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. 4 OZ, 120ML. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 210 units (pieces) from latest production

  • F-0461-2024 Class I

    Cotton Candy with M&Ms, ice-cream base, M&M's, artificial flavor, food coloring. DISTRIBUTED BY PARADISE FLAVORS LLC. 4 OZ. Packaged in plastic pouch. Frozen.

    Codes: None

    Quantity: 180 units (pieces) from latest production

Get new charts weekly

One email a week with the newest charts and their key numbers. No account needed.

Source and notes

U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Enforcement Reports (openFDA food recall data) (Public domain (U.S. government work); source U.S. Food and Drug Administration, openFDA), data as of November 22, 2023.

Each week the FDA lists the recalls it has classified in its Enforcement Report, often weeks after the company announced the recall, so a month with five weekly reports tends to count more. Each recall counts once, however many products it covers, in the month FDA first listed it. Class I means the food could cause serious harm or death, Class II temporary or minor harm, and Class III is unlikely to harm anyone. Meat, poultry and most egg products are recalled by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, not the FDA, and aren't included. For what to do with a recalled product, see the FDA's recalls page.